Guiding consumers since 2009

Debt review service is declared unlawful

By Staff Writer

The National Debt Mediation Association’s pilot debt mediation service, known as the Voluntary Debt Mediation Solution (VDMS), has been declared unlawful and banned from providing advice to consumers by the National Credit Regulator (NCR).


The finding requires the NDMA to stop its VDMS pilot scheme and provide written confirmation of its cessation by today (August 28).The Debt Counselling Industry portal (DCI) this week supported the finding by the regulator. The finding follows a complaint lodged by Deborah Solomon of the DCI to halt the VDMS as a Banking Association of South Africa initiative that prejudiced consumer rights and potentially favoured credit-providers while purporting to be a service to assist those in debt.


Solomon said: “The regulator’s finding that this scheme contravenes the NCA is a victory for the consumer and debt counsellor. It also returns respect and integrity to an already persecuted industry. For months, the NDMA has punted the benefits of its so-called ‘solution’ and certain banks have encouraged indebted individuals to go through these processes knowing their pilot scheme had not been approved by the regulator.”


“In effect, the NDMA and banks that eagerly supported this solution have misrepresented the true state of affairs to members of the public. They deliberately [and] negligently tried to circumvent the provisions of the NCA. They promoted a scheme that was supposedly beneficial to the public when the scheme compromised consumer rights. On top of that, the NDMA showed disrespect for debt counsellors, the regulator and the spirit of the NCA. They ought reasonably to have been aware that debt counsellors hold a fiduciary responsibility and cannot be beholden to the banks while working within the legally sanctioned system.”


NDMA CEO Magauta Mphahlele reportedly claimed there were “many abuses” in the debt counselling industry and cases where counsellors “absconded with the consumer’s money” or “messed up the process to such an extent the credit provider terminates the process and takes legal action”.


Solomon added: “These claims are biased, unsubstantiated and designed to undermine the public’s faith in independent debt review processes set up by the National Credit Act and thereby punt the NDMA. A few bad apples are not representative of an entire industry. This was a deliberate attack on the debt counselling industry in an effort to gain control of the debt review process that would enable credit providers to dictate the rules, processors and systems right down to the chosen debt counsellor.”


The NDMA denied it has contravened the law and will look to appeal the decision. “The VDMS is a credit industry initiative which was mandated by the Credit Industry Steering Committee (NISC) which is chaired by Mr Cas Coovadia of the Banking Association. The NDMA has referred the NCR letter to the Committee for consideration. The NDMA does not believe that it has contravened the law and will request the Industry Steering Committee to consider appealing the decision of the NCR. The NISC will communicate its final decision in due course,” said the NDMA in a statement.
 

When asked what will happen to the people currently getting advice under the scheme, the NDMA said: "The intention is to possibly take the matter on review as we are of the view that the process followed and the findings require further legal interrogation and interpretation. The outcome of these processes will determine what eventually happens to consumers already in the program. The full quota initially intended to be taken up will not be filled until the legal issues are resolved."
 

Recent Articles

Featured Debt counselling – the two sides of the coin

Being overindebted doesn’t just put a strain on your personal finances; it also puts a strain on your state of mind. The best solution is to start the process of debt counselling so that you can escape the debt cycle. But what are the ups and downs of joining this debt relief programme?

Travel ban – how to claim for the loss incurred

As with the recent Covid-19 pandemic, governments sometimes issue travel bans to prevent people from travelling to other countries. This becomes even more complicated if you’ve already planned and paid for your trip. Your flights will be cancelled, and you may lose money from cancelled accommodation arrangements. How do you claim for the financial losses incurred due to a travel ban?

How to finance and insure a second-hand vehicle

Buying a second-hand vehicle may suit your budget better than acquiring a new one. But what impact does an older model have on vehicle finance and car insurance? We reached out to specialists in the field to explain what the financial implications are of pursuing a second-hand vehicle.

Reading your loan agreement: look out for this

Many people don’t read their loan agreements. They just sign on the dotted line without realising that they could be signing their lives away. But it’s important to review your loan agreement before and after taking your loan to avoid future setbacks.

 

Deals

Udemy online course for R180

Price: R180
When: Until 27 March 2020
Where: Online

Educate your kids for free with Skills Share

Price: Free
When: Daily
Where: Online

Take advantage of payment holidays from Standard Bank and Nedbank

Price: Free
When: From 1 April to 30 June 2020
Where: Nationwide