Guiding consumers since 2009

Rescue plan for controversial medical guideline tariffs

By Staff Writer
In its quest to find common ground with a medical profession fiercely opposed to the regulation of medical practitioner fees, the Health Professions Council of South Africa (HPCSA) recently appointed healthcare actuary, Shivani Ramjee, to assist with the process of setting a guideline tariff that can be used to assess overcharging by medical practitioners.
 
Earlier this year the HPCSA extended the deadline for submissions to determine guideline tariffs for medical and dental services to 21 February 2013. 
Ramjee, a member of the Actuarial Society of South Africa and head of actuarial science at the University of Cape Town (UCT), said the absence of guideline tariffs for medical and dental practitioners created a problematic vacuum that left consumers unable to prove whether medical practitioners were overcharging them.
 
Previous attempts to impose guideline tariffs
 
According to Dr. Rajesh Patel, head of benefit and risk at the Board of Healthcare Funders, some members of the medical profession are opposed to the new guideline tariffs as they would no longer be able to exploit the situation by overcharging consumers.
Up to now if a medical practitioner is accused of overcharging their patients, the onus is on them to justify their fees.
 
The Health Professions Act does make provision for the establishment of a mechanism by which the HPCSA can determine whether a medical practitioner overcharged a patient by means of a “price norm” but this has yet to materialise. 
 
A previous attempt to introduce guideline tariffs was aborted last year after medical associations threatened legal action. The HPCSA was accused of having set guideline tariffs that were unreasonably low and calculated without scientific basis. With the help of a healthcare actuary, the HPCSA plans to make sure that future price norms will have a strong scientific basis.
Patel said that as Ramjee is an external consultant it would ensure that the process is without any political bias and beyond reproach.
 
“Since the setting of a norm will have financial implications for health professionals, funders and the general public this process needs to be fair, rational and lawful. Guideline tariffs must protect the right of medical practitioners to earn a fair living and recognise the fact that their skills are scarce. A pricing norm must also ensure the sustainability of private practice and ensure that the profession remains attractive to new entrants. Consumers, on the other hand, are entitled to fair and reasonable fees. Equally important is that patients are empowered to give informed consent based on transparent pricing structures,” said Ramjee.
 
What will the guidelines mean to the consumer?
 
Patel said that although the regulated tariffs are a step in the right direction, consumers need more certainty.
“There will be more transparency than before but what our country needs is a stipulated maximum regulation fee which would mean doctors can charge no more than a certain amount,” said Patel.

Recent Articles

Featured New homeowner? Be aware of these extra expenses

You’ve overcome all the hurdles of buying a home. You’ve managed to pay your deposit and your closing payments, and now you’re a proud title deed holder. However, there are other expenses waiting around the corner. Are you prepared?

Your biggest credit conundrums – answered

Understanding your credit health is one of the most important factors in managing your finances. This is because it gives you insight into your debt, your borrowing ability, and your financial history. While many understand this, there are still many questions on how to do just that.

Avoid debt collectors, choose debt counselling

There are two things you can do when you are struggling to pay your debt. You can either let your creditors hand your debt over to debt collectors – or you can let debt counsellors help you deal with your debt.

Retail notes: easy investment option for new investors

Being a newbie in the world of investing can be challenging because you don’t know where and how to invest. With so many investment options, you could easily be befuddled. Justmoney looks at how retail notes can help you cut your teeth in the world of investing.   

Deals

Spur's South African Combo Special

Price: R80
When: Mondays
Where: Nationwide

Translux Student Discount

Price: Depends on destination
When: Daily
Where: Nationwide

Zimbali Senior Citizens Discount

Price: From R1342.00
When: Until 14 December 2019
Where: KwaZulu Natal