Guiding consumers since 2009

Why your fund may not outperform the market

By Staff Writer
Nicolette Dirk, finance writer, Justmoney.co.za
 
Passively managed funds have traditionally been viewed as the less risky fund that comes with fairly low fees. 
Actively managed funds have been the option for investors hungry to beat the market average. 
 
But according to Steven Nathan, chief executive officer of 10X Investments, research is proving that it is simply not possible for most funds to outperform the market.
 
Is it possible to outperform the market?
 
The State Street Corporation (listed on the New York Stock Exchange) Centre for Applied Research report - The Quest for Performance -  found that only 1% of institutional investors were able to beat performance benchmarks once costs were deducted. The research analysed investment decisions made by university endowments, global pension funds, as well as sovereign wealth funds.
 
Louis van der Merwe, certified financial planner at Wealthup said that the context for investment in the US is different than in South Africa because of the market size.
 
“In America there is a bigger market and most of the performance of the funds is displayed. And most of these funds perform well,” said Van der Merwe.
For this reason you won’t necessarily get as big a return when you invest in an otherwise riskier actively managed fund.
 
Where do most South Africans invest?
 
“The vast majority of South African retirement funds are invested in actively managed funds with the expectation - or hope - of earning a market-beating return.

This higher or excess return is called “alpha” and South African retirement investors pay at least 1% per annum in extra investment fees for alpha,” said Nathan.  
 
He added that private sector retirement fund assets equal around R1.5 trillion (R1 500 billion), so the quest for alpha costs retirement savers around R15 billion every year. 
 
“Investors and trustees seem willing to pay the extra R15 billion, yet few understand what alpha is and how much of it is out there for all investors to share. This is how the industry wants it,” said Nathan.
 
According to Nathan competing for alpha – trying to beat the index – is a zero sum game because for every fund that buys a winning share, another fund must sell that winning share. In aggregate, the winners and losers cancel each other out to equal the market return.
 
“The fund management industry (including consultants) has managed to build a R15 billion per annum industry. It is a brilliant marketing feat, matched only by the success of bottled water.

The industry perpetuates this myth by promoting the few winning funds while ignoring the underperforming funds, which is where the majority of savers are invested,” said Nathan.
 
Are all passively managed funds the safer option?
 
Van Der Merwe said that with an exchange traded fund like Satrix you are able to buy a basket of shares (not actively traded, at a low cost) but there are also risks you should be aware of.
 
According to Wealthup, the Satrix Investment Plan starts with a 0.75% per annum administration fee on amounts below R100 000 for administration costs. The company also charges between 0.46% and 0.53% per annum depending on the fund. 
 
“Your total cost may easily reach more than 1%, which should still be below active managed funds, but is surely not the best priced funds in the market,” said Van der Merwe.
 
According to Van Der Merwe the Sanlam Investment Management’s equally weighted top 40 index fund is a good option. This is a pure equity fund which tracks the performance of the FTSE/JSE Equally Weighted Top 40 index. 
“The appeal is the .50% cost which is a good price and a good base for any investor,” said Van der Merwe.

Recent Articles

Featured How are you taxed on your retrenchment package?

Unemployment is one of the biggest problems in South Africa. The emergence of the Covid-19 pandemic has exacerbated the situation with a lot of companies retrenching their employees.  When retrenched, you’ll receive a retrenchment package, but do you know how much tax you’re liable for?

Car repossessed – don’t be taken for a ride

When the country is facing an economic downturn, chances are your finances will feel the pinch. This can lead you to make bad financial decisions such as skipping your vehicle payments. But every decision has consequences and if you don’t pay your instalment, the bank will repossess your car. But what can you do when this happens?

 

Why you should consider gap cover

Your medical aid should protect you from incurring large medical bills when you’re sick. But what if your plan doesn’t cover the full cost of your medical expenses? We got in touch with insurance experts to find out whether gap cover is worth having.

Debt relief - What is your bank offering?

Going through a financial crisis is stressful whether it be as a result of losing your job, being short-paid, having to fork out towards an emergency payment, or finding yourself in the midst of a global pandemic. This is especially taxing if you have a debt to service. It is against this backdrop that banks are increasingly offering payment holidays. Justmoney looks at the various debt relief options available to you from the big five banks.

Deals

Premier Hotel and Resorts Special For Senior Citizens

Price: Available on request
When: Daily
Where: Nationwide

The President hotel 10% discount for locals

Price: Available on request
When: Until 31 October 2020
Where: Cape Town

Get 40% off when you book your stay at Colosseum Hotel

Price: Available on request
When: Until 13 December
Where: Cape Town


Latest Guide

Guide to debt rehabilitation solutions