Guiding consumers since 2009

Amplats to sue debt collectors for overcharging

By Staff Writer
The local division of international mining company Anglo American Platinum (Amplats), together with seven of its employees have launched legal proceedings against law firm HVDM Attorneys, its administration business (HVDM Administrators), as well as the Minister of Justice, the Minister of Trade and Industry, and the National Credit Regulator, for what Amplats believes is "unlawful" overcharging of debt administration.
Amplats and its employees are accusing HVDM and its admin business of "unlawfully deducting fees and remuneration in excess of the 12,5% cap imposed by s 74L(2) of the Magistrates' Court Act 32 of 1944".
Industry reaction
CEO of debt counselling firm DebtBusters Ian Wason welcomed the move: "Amplats should be applauded for these actions to protect their employees, it is just a shame that it has taken so long for a responsible employer to stand up against this. I think most employers will watch from the sidelines and see how this plays out, but if successful it could lead to a slew of similar actions."
In the affidavit Amplats and its employees argued that the fee that attorneys charge when carrying out administration work should be capped at 12,5%, the same rate which applies to administrators.
The abuse of emoluments attachment orders (also known as garnishee orders), which require employers to deduct amounts owing to creditors from employees' salaries was also raised. In many cases, EAOs leave workers in bad financial standing for longer, as they do not receive their full income.
Industry abuse?
Besides accusing the firm and its administrators for charging too much, Amplats and its employees allege that EAOs were granted in favour of the administrators, not taking into consideration the (negative) impact that this could have on the employees.
The affidavit further stated: "In these proceedings, the applicants seek to clarify certain aspects of the regime governing administration orders granted under ss 74 to 74W of the MCA. The regime is being abused by the first to third respondents who, at best, take advantage of uncertainties as to the proper interpretation of these statutory provisions."
Wason said this case is another blow to the debt collection and garnishee order industry, which has had bad press over the past year. This, in turn, has led magistrate courts to act more carefully and within tighter guidelines when granting garnishee orders.
According to Wason, although the fees that law firms charge when acting as administrators are regulated, this additional cost can be excessive and add significantly to the consumer's financial burdens.
To better combat the issue of administrator fees and how much the consumers are charged, Wason said: "Ideally these fees should be reduced and better regulated. There is obviously a moral hazard if consumers feel they can get away with not paying their debts, but I do not think that garnishee orders should be used for such things. Garnishee orders should be used for maintenance payments and similar instances."
HVDM's response
Justmoney contacted CEO of HVDM Attorneys Hannatjie Pienaar for comment on the allegations made against HVDM Attorneys and the HVDM Administrators. Pienaar said: "The matter should be left in the hands of the court, but I believe that the allegations are unfounded."

Recent Articles

Featured What’s the deal with underwriting?

When you apply for a long-term insurance policy, a financial adviser will ask some personal questions about your lifestyle, family history, health, and even ask you to take some medical tests. This process is called underwriting, but is it really necessary?


How are you taxed on your retrenchment package?

Unemployment is one of the biggest problems in South Africa. The emergence of the Covid-19 pandemic has exacerbated the situation with a lot of companies retrenching their employees.  When retrenched, you’ll receive a retrenchment package, but do you know how much tax you’re liable for?

Car repossessed – don’t be taken for a ride

When the country is facing an economic downturn, chances are your finances will feel the pinch. This can lead you to make bad financial decisions such as skipping your vehicle payments. But every decision has consequences and if you don’t pay your instalment, the bank will repossess your car. But what can you do when this happens?


Why you should consider gap cover

Your medical aid should protect you from incurring large medical bills when you’re sick. But what if your plan doesn’t cover the full cost of your medical expenses? We got in touch with insurance experts to find out whether gap cover is worth having.


Office furniture at discounted prices at BDK

Price: Available on request
When: Daily
Where: Johannesburg

Da Vincis Happy Hour Special

Price: Available on request
When: Daily
Where: Cape Town

Use your Absa card and get 30% cashback at Dis-chem

Price: Available on request
When: Daily
Where: Nationwide

Latest Guide

Guide to debt rehabilitation solutions