Guiding consumers since 2009

Moody’s follows suit with ratings downgrade

By Jessica Anne Wood

Ratings agency Moody’s is the latest to downgrade South Africa’s long-term issuer and senior unsecured ratings. This follows downgrades by Standard & Poor’s and Fitch earlier this year. However, unlike the other two ratings agencies, Moody’s still has South Africa one notch above sub-investment grade. The downgrades follow a number of political and economy issues the country has faced in recent months, including the cabinet reshuffle by President Jacob Zuma.

Among the key drivers for the credit ratings downgrade according to Moody’s were:

  • The weakening of South Africa's institutional framework.
  • Reduced growth prospects reflecting policy uncertainty and slower progress with structural reforms.
  • The continued erosion of fiscal strength due to rising public debt and contingent liabilities.

“The downgrade reflects Moody's view that recent political developments suggest a weakening of the country's institutional strength which casts doubt over the strength and sustainability of the recovery in growth and the stabilisation of the debt-to-GDP ratio over the near-term,” said Moody’s.

The ratings agency added: “The negative outlook reflects Moody's view that the risks to growth and fiscal strength arising from the political outlook are tilted to the downside. It is unlikely that a political consensus will emerge which supports investment in the economy and reinvigorates the reform effort sufficiently quickly to reverse the expected negative impact on growth and on the government's balance sheet. The opposite scenario, of heightened political dysfunction, continued gradual institutional weakening and diminished clarity over policy objectives, has a higher likelihood.”

Reactions to the downgrade

According to Prof Raymond Parsons, an economist at the NWU School of Business and Governance, Moody’s latest decision regarding the country’s investment rating should be seen as a warning. “As expected Moody's have reduced SA's investment rating by one notch - keeping it at investment grade, but just above junk status and retaining a 'negative outlook'.”

Parsons highlighted that a positive of the downgrade is that the country is still in the global bond index, which impacts on borrowing costs for South Africa. “This grants SA a breathing space and gives scope for remedial policies and actions. Yet the continued negative outlook categorization and Moody's critical but balanced narrative means that their decision should not be viewed as a reprieve, but rather as a warning for SA to get its house in order. Moody's sees the risks to growth and fiscal strength associated with the political outlook as now being tilted to the downside,” clarified Parsons.

The Democratic Alliance (DA) said that Moody’s ratings decision “is a clear vote of no confidence in finance minister Malusi Gigaba and President Jacob Zuma.”

David Maynier, DA Shadow Minister of Finance, noted that the party has written to Speaker of the National Assembly, Baleka Mbete, calling for a debate on measures that can be taken to combat the recession, ratings downgrades and mass unemployment in South Africa.

The future outlook

Moody’s pointed out: “The future trajectory of the rating will depend on the government's success in safeguarding South Africa's institutional, economic and fiscal strength. Indications that the strength and independence of the country's institutions have diminished to a greater extent than in Moody's baseline scenario, or that the emerging policy framework has become even less predictable or has shifted in a way likely to undermine economic or fiscal strength, could lead to a further downgrade. Further delays in growth enhancing reforms would be suggestive of such a shift. Downward pressure could also develop if liquidity pressures begin to re-emerge at state-owned enterprises that would elicit pronounced government intervention, be it through the activation of guarantees or other measures.”

“Conversely, Moody's could change the rating outlook from negative to stable if the government were to deliver on commitments that indicated the continued independence and strong policy-making capabilities of South Africa's policy institutions, and which enhanced medium-term growth and achieved the planned stabilisation in the government's debt burden. A decline in the value of guarantees to state-owned enterprises would also be credit positive,” highlighted Moody’s.

Recent Articles

Featured How to earn passive income through dividends on your investments

If you invest your money wisely, you will be able to watch it grow beyond inflation. This is a far better option than simply leaving your money in a general savings account. However, did you know that you could also receive interest or dividend payments on your investments?

This is why you should ask your medical scheme for an annual claims statement

Even with a strict budget, a lot can happen in a year and you may lose track of your medical expenses, especially the costs that you cover out-of-pocket. It’s important to regularly assess your medical aid or hospital plan contribution.

Make rewards programmes work for you

Many retailers and financial service providers have introduced rewards programmes, or loyalty programmes, to retain their customers and make them feel appreciated. These programmes can help you save money, but you have to know how to make them work for you.


Top 5 things to consider before taking on further credit

Nowadays, the process of attaining credit has become easier and faster. Although applying for, and receiving cash on the same day may excite potential lenders, it doesn’t come without serious repercussions if you’re not wise. 


Get 25% off your stay at Monte Vista Boutique Hotel

Price: Available on request
When: Until 31 January 2021
Where: Montagu

Luxury Spa Package Special for R449 at Aurora

Price: R449
When: Until 31 January 2021
Where: Cape Town

Oyster and Champagne Special at Blowfish Restaurant | JustMoney

Price: R129
When: Daily
Where: Cape Town

Latest Guide

Guide to debt rehabilitation solutions