Guiding consumers since 2009

Virtual Meltdown?

By Staff Writer

 From theage.com.au/

 January 15 2008

By Nick Miller

The bank is packed with customers: red-haired elves, fetishists in their underwear, spunky girls with furry tails. And they all want their money back. Yep, there's a banking meltdown in the 3-D virtual world Second Life, too. Seems that it's virtually impossible to avoid the global financial crisis.

Even in the internet depths of Linden Lab's Second Life, avatars are milling around the foyers of virtual banks, demanding the government take real action to stop their virtual money disappearing.

The panic began late last Tuesday, US time, when Linden said it would strictly regulate the banks in Second Life, after one collapsed amid a credit crunch that Linden said posed "unique and substantial risks to Second Life ... likely to lead to destabilisation of the virtual economy". It sparked a run on in-world banks.

Second Life's economy is based on the Linden dollar ($L), which buys virtual products and services.

It can be exchanged with the US dollar for about $L270 to $US1 ($A1.12). Some less scrupulous virtual-world inhabitants built "banks", or "ATMs", that were Ponzi schemes: paying high interest rates with the money of other depositors.

They helped juice the economy but were unsustainable. Last August, Ginko Financial offered 44% interest but collapsed after a crash in confidence and a run of withdrawals, leaving customers $US700,000 out of pocket.

Despite a policy of generally leaving Second Life as an uncontrolled experiment, Linden Lab has decided enough is enough - as it did with gambling and simulated pedophilia.

From January 22, it will prohibit offering interest or any direct return on an investment in Second Life without proof of an applicable government registration statement or financial institution charter.


"Linden Lab has received complaints about several in-world 'banks' defaulting on promises," it said.


"These banks often promise unusually high rates of $L return, reaching 20, 40, or even 60% annualised. As these activities grow, they become more likely to destabilise the virtual economy."

But Linden's action has destabilised the economy. Late on Wednesday, US time, the well-established virtual bank

JT Financial announced: "The system has temporarily suspended trading ... due to price fluctuation." It described the crisis as "truly one of Second Life's darkest hours" but promised to honour withdrawal requests and assured customers it was "100% solvent".

It's not only banks complaining. Commentator Shaun Rolph has pointed out that Second Life could be considered a Ponzi scheme, as Linden does not guarantee any right of redemption for $L to real money.

Another commentator, Aldon Hynes at Orient Lodge, says there are plenty of loopholes left for dodgy financial operators in the virtual world, but Linden has apparently banned legitimate actions.

Benjamin Duranske, founder of the Second Life Bar Association, blogged that "it is

a smart move from both a business and legal perspective, and it stands as further evidence that Linden Lab is growing up".

The move has also sparked heated discussion in various online forums about what "virtual economy" actually means, whether a virtual bank can be a real investment opportunity, whether real-world money is in fact real, and what the hell does "real" really mean. I mean ... really?

Recent Articles

Featured It’s possible to change your marriage regime

Many people wed before they sign an antenuptial contract (ANC). This is especially practiced by people in customary marriages and those not clued up about the ANC. The law says if there’s no ANC before the wedding takes place, the marriage will automatically be in Community of Property. 

Keep this in mind when taking out new financial products

Adding a product to your personal finance portfolio, such as insurance or an investment, is a big decision. We found out what you should keep in mind before taking out a new product, how you can assess the products you already have, and how you can generally improve your financial position.

Are you in debt denial?

With debt levels increasing at 13% more than income levels, South Africans are more debt-stressed now than arguably ever before. This is iterated by the National Credit Regulator’s (NCR) report that nearly half of credit-active consumers in South Africa have damaged credit records. However, only a few seek the necessary help.

Why should you invest in a mutual bank?

Often when people think about banking, they always think about commercial banks. Mutual banks hardly come to mind, but these banks offer investment opportunities that are often overlooked.

 

Deals

Aurora Spa 100-minute Treatment Special

Price: R449
When: Until 31 March
Where: Century City

Woodstock Grill and Tap Steak Thursdays

Price: R100
When: Thursdays
Where: Woodstock

KFC 5+5 Special

Price: R65
When: Until 25 February 2020
Where: Nationwide